Grape growers face restrictions on stream-water use
Robert Digitale
Press Democrat
12/13/2009
A showdown is looming between grape growers and the agency tasked with protecting fish in the Russian River.
Russian River grape growers are collecting data to counter a nearing state decision on how to protect endangered fish from the impacts of water pumping for frost protection.
The state Water Resources Control Board is contemplating new regulations along the river after federal fish managers declared that water diversions for frost protection have harmed salmon and steelhead.
Three environmental groups are pressuring the state to adopt strict rules. Last month, the groups formally notified the water board of their intent to sue the state under the federal Endangered Species Act.
A spokesman for one of the three environmental groups said the fish will remain at risk of extinction unless the state takes decisive action and rejects the idea of self-regulation by growers.
“We don’t really have time to sit around and spend 10 years discussing half measures that may or may not work,” said Jeff Miller of the Center for Biological Diversity.
The other two environmental groups are Northern California River Watch and Coast Action Group.
Farm leaders in Sonoma and Mendocino counties counter that since the federal regulators brought the issue to the forefront in 2008, they have made great strides to reduce impacts on salmon and steelhead. That includes the construction of new reservoirs near Hopland, the site of fish strandings in 2008.
“We’re here to protect fish as well, but it can’t be done by eliminating the viticulture industry in Mendocino and Sonoma County,” said Devon Jones, executive director of the Mendocino County Farm Bureau.
On freezing nights in spring, many growers spray water over their vineyards to protect the vines from damage. The irrigation water freezes and encapsulates the green buds in ice, keeping the plant tissue safe at a constant 32-degree temperature.
But the National Marine Fisheries Service has called for limits on the diversion of stream water after frost protection stranded and killed fish in 2008. The strandings affected endangered coho salmon and threatened steelhead, and occurred again last spring.
“Based on the information that we have, it appears that frost protection has a significant impact on ESA-listed species,” said Steve Edmondson, the service’s Northern California habitat manager based in Santa Rosa.
Five grower meetings will occur from Jan. 6 to 14 in the river basin in Sonoma County.
“It is really critical that all growers get involved with this,” said Nick Frey, president of the 1,800-member Sonoma County Wine Grape Commission.
This spring “there’s a risk of not everyone having water for frost protection,” Frey said.
The water board could take action as early as Jan. 5, although an agenda for that meeting has yet to be released. Several observers said the board appears ready to put new rules in place before frost protection begins in March.
